In this
week’s articles, I found the topic of sociolinguistics to be very fascinating
and relatable to everyday life experiences.
I thought
that Sumner’s article, “The social weight of spoken words” was the most
relatable to me. Growing up with parents who were non-native English speakers,
there was definitely a social bias against their speech. People would give my parent’s
a hard time due to their heavy Chinese accent, but when a British speaker
spoke, people would fall in love with their speech. The discrimination against “unpleasant”
sounding accent affects how people comprehend someone’s speech. If it is a more
“pleasant” sounding accent like a British accent, people choose to understand it
more. This discrimination has been built from society grouping these accents
and causing people to stigmatize different accents.
This
relates to the King and Sumner article where people have their own interpretations
and expectations of what a speaker should be saying based on their identity. For
example, the difference between a man and a woman’s voice affects how a
listener takes in speech. Usually a male’s voice is more authoritative due to the
patriarchy created in the past. So, when a female speaks in an authoritative setting
or context, people may be more taken back by what the speaker is saying and
question the truthfulness because the speaker is female. If the speaker is a
male, there are usually less doubts about what the speaker is saying due to the
stigma that male speakers are usually more authoritative.
Lastly, in Sumner
and Kataoka’s article, it mentions that GA speakers recognize words uttered by
BE speakers. As mentioned before, I believe this is a choice that people make
and due to the more pleasant sounding accent British speakers have, GA speakers
choose to understand and recall words that are uttered by BE speakers.
There definitely is social bias for and against certain accents; my grandparents have Indian accents, so they have experienced the same thing as your parents. Clearly, there is stigmatization of different accents, and some are perceived more as "pleasant" while other--like British--accents are perceived as "unpleasant." But if there is a range from "unpleasant" to "pleasant" accents, where do we place our own accents and are there any accents that fall in the middle of this spectrum?
ReplyDelete